BISMARCK, ND, August 7, 1998
The North Dakota Fair Housing Council (NDFHC) and six Bismarck residents filed a federal
lawsuit today against John Haider, a Bismarck property owner, charging discriminatory
housing practices.
Amy Nelson, Executive Director of the NDFHC stated, "John Haider has violated
the civil rights of numerous Bismarck residents and its shocking that this sort of
thing is happening in our community."
Since 1995, the NDFHC has received over 15 complaints of discrimination against Mr.
Haider. On the basis of the complaints, the NDFHC conducted an investigation of Mr.
Haiders business operations. Mr. Haider owns apartments throughout Bismarck.
The investigation by the NDFHC confirmed the basis for the complaints. The complaint
charges that Mr. Haider routinely denies rental housing to unmarried couples, single
mothers and families with children. The investigation found that when prospective tenants
tell Mr. Haider that they are not married or a single mother, Mr. Haider often refuses to
show them apartments, tries to steer them into undesirable units, or charges them more
rent for the units than he would a married couple.
The investigation also found that families with young children were steered to certain
units. These practices violate both federal and state laws against housing discrimination.
"As we conducted our investigation, it became very clear that there were a number
of discrepancies in apartment availability and price and how people were treated based
solely upon whether they were a single mother, an unmarried couple, or because of their
age or national origin," explained Nelson.
In addition, the complaint charges that Mr. Haider told one fair housing investigator
that he would not rent to Native Americans because they are dirty. He also stated that he
would not rent to anyone on housing assistance. He claimed that he would not rent to
divorced women because they had violated their marriage vows, and therefore, they would
not be good renters.
Several Bismarck residents who were denied housing by Mr. Haider are also part of the
lawsuit. The complaint charges that one Bismarck resident was looking for housing for
herself and her three children and called Mr. Haider about available apartments that were
being advertised. Mr. Haider refused to show her any of his available apartments, saying
that he only rented to families that included a man. Two Bismarck couples were also denied
from inspecting available apartments because they were not married.
Mr. Haider also denied housing to a nineteen year old male and his three roommates
because they were too young, according to the complaint. Mr. Haider told a fair housing
investigator that he thinks all teenagers are hoodlums and that he refuses to rent to
college students. It is illegal in North Dakota to deny housing on the basis of age.
The federal law that governs housing discrimination is the Fair Housing Act (FHA),
which was passed by Congress in 1968. The FHA forbids discrimination in the sale, rental
or financing of housing on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, gender,
familial status (presence of children), or disability. The North Dakota Century Code on
Human Rights forbids similar kinds of discrimination and also gives further protection to
individuals on the basis of age, source of income, and marital status.
The North Dakota Fair Housing Council is a North Dakota non-profit organization located
in Bismarck. The NDFHCs mission is to provide support, encouragement, and assistance
to those seeking equal access to housing in the state of North Dakota. The NDFHC also
investigates complaints of housing discrimination.
This case was filed simultaneously in federal District Court in Bismarck and the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development, which enforces the FHA. The NDFHC and the
individual plaintiffs are represented in the lawsuit by Calvin Rolfson, a Bismarck lawyer,
and by Christopher Brancart, a lawyer from Pescadero, California who specializes in fair
housing litigation.